from Amazon
Tuesday, November 01, 2011
Fielding Bible 2011 - Complete Vote Tally
Here you go.
Looking quickly at the results by position, and comparing the Fans Scouting Report to the consensus:
1B: No big surprises, with Fans wanting Pujols, and him winning. The top 6 votegetters were in the top 9 for the Fans.
2B: Even more of a match to consensus, including #1 Pedroia. The only ones to have Espinoza ranked highly are the Fans, Strat-O-Matic, and Doug Glanville.
SS: Good match overall, including #1 Tulo.
3B: Good match overall, including #1 Beltre.
LF: Solid match overall, with Fans’ #2 Gardner being consensus #1. CarGo ranked #1 by Fans, and #2 by Strat-O-Matic, and #7 overall.
CF: This one is really a tough one, because there’s so little separating all the top CFers.
RF: Very little agreement.
C: Fairly strong agreement at the top, including #1 Matt Wieters.
So, Fans matched the #1 on all the infield positions, and catcher, and had the consensus #1 as #2 in LF. CF and RF had much less agreement.
***
As for pitcher, I used my own quick algorithm to get the rankings. I expect little match.
Recent comments
Older comments
Page 1 of 344 pages 1 2 3 > Last »Complete Archive – By Category
Complete Archive – By Date