THE BOOK cover
The Unwritten Book is Finally Written!
An in-depth analysis of: The sacrifice bunt, batter/pitcher matchups, the intentional base on balls, optimizing a batting lineup, hot and cold streaks, clutch performance, platooning strategies, and much more.
Read Excerpts & Customer Reviews

Buy The Book from Amazon


SABR101 required reading if you enter this site. Check out the Sabermetric Wiki. And interesting baseball books.
MOST RECENT ARTICLES
MAIL : You ask | We say

Advanced


THE BOOK--Playing The Percentages In Baseball

<< Back to main

Wednesday, March 03, 2010

MLB pitcher or NHL goalie?  Which sport will break the woman barrier?

By Tangotiger, 12:00 PM

MLB has a good chance:

“I’m impressed,” Wakefield said. “She spun a couple, but for the most part it was very good. She was able to take the spin out of a lot of them and they had quite a lot of movement on them.”

Yoshida, who stands 5-foot-1 and throws her knuckleball with a sidearm motion, is in the United States to pitch in the independent Arizona Winter League. She got her first win on Feb. 12, tossing four shutout innings for the Yuma Scorpions. But she admitted she was nervous working with the 43-year-old Wakefield.


#1    Peter Jensen      (see all posts) 2010/03/03 (Wed) @ 13:18

Very cool!  I hope she becomes a star.


#2          (see all posts) 2010/03/03 (Wed) @ 13:47

I’ve long thought a female knuckleballer could make it in the majors, and at least be as good as Sidney Ponson for a bit.

Problem is, I think I read that the knuckler gets it’s peak amount of movement somewhere around 68-72 mph (or, is hardest to hit at that speed, or something).  It’s tough to throw a ball that fast, let alone a knuckleball.  I can’t imagine there’s too many people 5’1” on the planet, male or female, that can throw a knuckler anywhere near that speed.

I think the first female pitcher in the MLB is going to be six feet tall, or be built like a bodybuilder.


#3    Spencer      (see all posts) 2010/03/03 (Wed) @ 15:21

I’ve always said that one of the only places in the big 4 professional leagues (NBA, MLB, NFL, NHL) where a woman could conceivably break into would be as a knuckleball pitcher.  Yoshida may not throw hard enough to make it but a much taller girl may be able to, think 6 feet tall. 

The only other places I could imagine a girl competing would be as a goalie (highly unlikely but i’ll entertain the notion) or as a super accurate field goal kicker from 45 yards and in (like Kathy Ireland)


#4          (see all posts) 2010/03/03 (Wed) @ 19:24

Last year she was on TV quite a bit as the face of a newly formed Kansai professional league here in Japan. First female professional player in Japan at any rate.


#5    Richard Gadsden      (see all posts) 2010/03/04 (Thu) @ 15:05

I don’t get why women play fast-pitch softball instead of baseball at HS/college/semi-pro/Olympic level.

If there was a regular women’s pro-baseball league and the NCAA recognised women’s baseball, then I suspect that the next generation would choose to switch to baseball from FP softball.  Once they are playing baseball in numbers, the chances of a knuckleballer emerging eventually would go up in a big way.

In fact, what does a really top woman’s fastball look like?  We probably don’t know, but if 90mph for a woman is the equivalent to 100mph for a man, then a woman who’d be a top starter in a women’s league might be able to pitch middle relief in MLB.


#6    Tangotiger      (see all posts) 2010/03/04 (Thu) @ 15:14

There was a woman that pitched on an independent team many years ago.  I think her FB was in the low 80s.

***

The reason for softball I presume is for participation levels.  Make it baseball, and you lose 75% of your participants.  They play for fun, not for pro aspirations.


#7    Drewg      (see all posts) 2010/03/05 (Fri) @ 09:15

Also, if you switch to baseball, you need a lot more pitchers per team. With fast pitch softball and the quick recovery times, most high schools can get away with having just 1 or 2 pitchers.

That’s a big deal, especially for small schools, who may only have 10-12 girls on the entire roster.


#8    sean      (see all posts) 2010/03/05 (Fri) @ 14:00

Tango/6:

Yep, Ila Borders. Not surprisingly, she’s a lefty.


#9    Tangotiger      (see all posts) 2010/03/05 (Fri) @ 14:17

Riiiiiiight, I was trying to remember her name.  Good job.


Page 1 of 1 pages


Name (required)
E-Mail (optional; WILL be published)
Website (optional)

<< Back to main


Latest...

COMMENTS

Feb 12 05:18
Reader Mail of the Day: Why do we need X years of fielding data?  And what about outliers?

Feb 12 04:55
Who is Jeremy Lin?

Feb 12 03:15
New PECOTA

Feb 12 02:42
Whitney Houston

Feb 12 02:23
Psst… wanna intern in Canada?

Feb 12 00:40
Clutch analogy

Feb 11 20:11
Fighting leads to goals?

Feb 11 19:55
Why do players get crappy caps?

Feb 11 19:12
Hero of the month: Brittney Baxter

Feb 11 17:59
MGL: Today on Clubhouse Confidential