THE BOOK cover
The Unwritten Book is Finally Written!
An in-depth analysis of: The sacrifice bunt, batter/pitcher matchups, the intentional base on balls, optimizing a batting lineup, hot and cold streaks, clutch performance, platooning strategies, and much more.
Read Excerpts & Customer Reviews

Buy The Book from Amazon


SABR101 required reading if you enter this site. Check out the Sabermetric Wiki. And interesting baseball books.
MOST RECENT ARTICLES
MAIL : You ask | We say

Advanced


THE BOOK--Playing The Percentages In Baseball

<< Back to main

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

David v Goliath: Romeo Filip v MLB

By Tangotiger, 04:15 PM

Here’s the link to the whole story, and here’s the letter David fired to Goliath, crude language and all:


This bullshit packet that you have sent out is just another clear violation of everything our country stands against. MLB, MLBPA, YOU, and your staff have been robbing good hard working people for long enough. Your regulations are as big a crock of shit as your players integrity. You have the [nerve] to send this packet to us after we bust our asses sitting in the rain waiting to sell our products. We bend over backwards and kiss ass to every idiot clubhouse manager in the league. We get no special treatment, no respect, and no direct contact to players. We set up at 5:00am in the parking lots for your teams just to watch Louisville Slugger reps walk right past us directly into the clubhouse. We get shit on by you, the teams, the agents, and even players from time to time. We take this abuse from you for what??? We do this so you can send us this bullshit approval process that no owner in his right mind should stand for. Who do you guys think you are? Who the hell made you idiots the know it alls when it comes to bat making.

How many bats have you made in your lifetime Krasik? How many maple, ash, or yellow birch billets have you sorted for quality? How many custom orders have you processed and hand delivered to the players? The answer is zero. Zero, like the amount of information you have on bat making. You and your idiot detectives (aka, Louisville Slugger) have been in bed together since this approval process started. We tailor our hand created products to your specifications just to watch Louisville Slugger build whatever they like. The morons you hired to do this amazing research have put together a list of the stupidest regulations ever assembled on one piece of paper. Who the hell came up with hitting against the grain. You idiots have to be the stupidest people I have ever come across. A 15 year old high school player can tell you that hitting against the grain is outrageous.

Along with all this you dare raise the administration fee and the insurance requirements to over $50,000.00 per year! We are in a recession you fucking idiots. Hundreds of people are losing their business, jobs, and well being in these harsh times. What do you fucking greedy idiots come up with. Make it harder for us. Kick us further while we are down. Hurt our business more and make it harder for us to put food on our families tables. You Mr. Krasik are a FUCKING thief. MLB is a fucking thief. You steal from the poor and give money to the rich.

I wonder how much you’re sorry ass gets paid to kill businesses and destroy lives. I’m sure your overpaid sorry ass gets a 6 figure paycheck. I’m sure your just fine in these tough times. I’m sure you will not lose a minute of sleep when you notice only a handful of bat companies were able to pay your ransom. I’m just wondering how your Christmas is going to be this year. I’m sure you have finished your shopping and wrapped your presents. I’m sure your planning on driving your Mercedes to your family’s house for a big turkey dinner. Guess what we are doing this year Mr. Krasik. We are holding on for dear life just so we don’t go bankrupt. We are saving every penny we can for the rainy days ahead. We aren’t buying gifts because we all understand how hard times are, and how [bad] the economy really is.

So, while you’re sitting around this Christmas handing out hundreds of dollars in presents to the ones you care for, think about all the families and business you have managed to destroy. Think about the hand you played in putting these things through. Think about all of the hard working people you are going to put out of business. When your all done with that, remember me, Romeo Filip, proud owner of Diablo Bats. Remember that I personally told you to go fuck yourself and stick this approval letter up your ass.

P.S. Merry Christmas

#1    Craig      (see all posts) 2009/01/22 (Thu) @ 15:52

One interesting thing that was pointed out in the article was how maple bats have larger sweet spots but don’t hit the ball farther.  It’d be interesting to know if maple bats hit knuckleballers betters, because they work primarily by preventing you from hitting the sweet spot.  That I think would definitively disprove MLB’s argument.


#2    Tangotiger      (see all posts) 2009/01/22 (Thu) @ 16:02

Yes, what I found interesting is how the “controlled” environment may not be the best environment, if they don’t replicate the actual environment.  It’s all well-and-good to say that you are creating a model where a ball is thrown to a bat, but “swing and miss”, “fouls”, different planes for the bat and ball to go through need to be part of the whole model.

So, it’s interesting how no matter how careful you try to construct a model, that it will have gaps to reality.


#3          (see all posts) 2009/01/22 (Thu) @ 16:38

Well we don’t know that maple has a larger sweet spot, right?  The players just think it does.

Filip’s rant bugs me because he takes the classic “nerds in the basement” stance - assuming that because someone hasn’t built bats with their bare hands, their scientific results mean nothing.  It makes me less sympathetic towards his more valid point, which is that the MLB appears to be stifling innovation and competition in regards to allowing small volume manufacturers to operate a business.


#4    Tangotiger      (see all posts) 2009/01/22 (Thu) @ 16:45

I agree that the “nerds in the basement” argument holds no water (here, or anywhere), but I would not use that to detract from his other legitimate point regarding the stifling of competition.  Just gloss over the nerds part to give it the attention it deserves.


#5    Craig      (see all posts) 2009/01/22 (Thu) @ 20:08

Mike - The point is that MLB has done some lab testing (which although I don’t have access to the test info, I bet it something like hook a bat up to a controlled swing machine, and see how far it hits a ball).  This data indicates that the maple bat has a larger sweet spot than ash but hits the ball the same distance.  However, as tango points out, that probably isn’t enough to really know what happens.  You’d like to know which players use which bats when and control across MLB and see if it matters.  I don’t think that data exists publicly.
But yeah, Romeo Filips arguments about MLB not making bats is almost entirely spurious to any reasonable discussion about the importance of maple.


#6    MGL      (see all posts) 2009/01/23 (Fri) @ 02:22

Just from reading the article, I don’t really see anything wrong that MLB did.  In fact, it is a really bad article in terms of criticizing MLB.


#7    Justin      (see all posts) 2010/08/30 (Mon) @ 17:39

No, Romeo said it right. What MLB did was very bad. In regards to their fee’s for acceptance going up from 5 grand to 50 grand this was done because Louisville Slugger was loosing all their clients and in a back door deal LS convinced or paid MLB to have the rate increased to push out several vendors. At this time LS was on a campaign o buy out several of these small companies, or hire out their employee’s to drive them out of business. It failed btw. And the TECO report is very misleading. What they are saying is if the bat’s slop of grain is with n limits and the balls are being hit of the face grain and it breaks the bat should not slip into two pieces, it should stay intact. And they are right. BUT! Hitting off the face grain has very negative side effects. One being you are not going to have as much pop hitting off the softer, more flexible side of the bat. And one hit off the end or logo with break the bat every time hitting off the face grains. Player are just hitting with the logo up and are still hitting off the edge grain. This will never change. This whole debate is a witch hunt.


Page 1 of 1 pages


Name (required)
E-Mail (optional; WILL be published)
Website (optional)

<< Back to main


Latest...

COMMENTS

Feb 12 03:15
New PECOTA

Feb 12 02:42
Whitney Houston

Feb 12 02:23
Psst… wanna intern in Canada?

Feb 12 01:57
Who is Jeremy Lin?

Feb 12 00:40
Clutch analogy

Feb 12 00:38
Reader Mail of the Day: Why do we need X years of fielding data?  And what about outliers?

Feb 11 20:11
Fighting leads to goals?

Feb 11 19:55
Why do players get crappy caps?

Feb 11 19:12
Hero of the month: Brittney Baxter

Feb 11 17:59
MGL: Today on Clubhouse Confidential