Wednesday, October 18, 2006
Game Theory in Football
A look at whether teams should pass more on 1st and ten, from Ben Alamar.
The key data for those who don’t want to read the whole thing is…
Buy The Book from Amazon
A look at whether teams should pass more on 1st and ten, from Ben Alamar.
The key data for those who don’t want to read the whole thing is…
Rob McQuown has a good understanding of how to use the win expectancy table. I wouldn’t go as low as “ to about .250-.260.” when you get to that part, maybe down to .270 as a guess. And in THE BOOK, I do show how the breakeven point can be anywhere from 60% to 90% depending on the inning and score, so the adherence to the “average” breakeven point obviously should not be listened to. The important takeaways from the articles are:
1 - Understand the context, don’t assume average
2 - You should be able to use some educated guesses to tweak the numbers to fit a particular context
I loved the whole article. The premise to the analysis:
On the other hand, any gambler going to Vegas to play blackjack will, if he or she is serious about winning, come equipped with a memorized cheat-sheet of when to take a hit and when to stand pat. Should we expect anything less from the man in charge of a baseball team with a $70 million budget? The odds we’re dealing with are small, but so is the house advantage in Vegas. To beat the system, or the other team, is a matter of inches, or, precisely the issue at hand here: a few percentage points. After all, that’s supposed to be the point of conventional baseball strategy in the first place--playing the percentages.
This was written by Joe Sheehan in today’s BP. Joe is a smart guy and a sabermetric writer. When these guys write fluff pieces, do they turn into blithering idiots, with all due respect to Joe, who is also a nice guy? O.K., I am being a little harsh, but these things really piss me off and I am getting too old to pull any punches.
Nothing worse than arguing about the strategy of the bunt by using words like “Moneyball” to represent the sabermetric-viewpoint. There’s a great set of charts by Dan Levitt along with the important series of disclaimers of not looking at averages but at the actual sequence of runners/batters, as well as a 50-page treatise by MGL in THE BOOK. You need to immerse yourself in these two pieces of research, before writing about when to use and not use the bunt.
When Bonds was Bonds the shift probably did not hurt him all that much overall, or at least the decrease in production from the shift was but a mere drop in the bucket compared to his overall offensive production.
Now that he is no longer Bonds, I am beginning to wonder if the shift is really hurting his overall offensive value.
If you have a lapse in judgement, is it enough to call you stupid? So, we have the Braves game, with the resident power hitter, bunting in the ninth inning of a close game:
Manuel insists on batting three lefties in a row, Dellucci, Utley, and Howard.
Last night in the bottom of the 14th inning, the Reds IBB’d Howard with runners on 1st and 2nd and no outs and the game tied.
Andy penned an article on pinch hitting at Baseball Prospectus:
http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=5404
Barry Bonds was intentionally walked with the bases loaded, a 2-run lead, in the bottom of the ninth, and 2 outs on May 28, 1998. Was it a good play or not?
May 16 22:50
Dodgers’ win reversed because Mattingly did not attest to proper score!
May 16 20:44
How to beat the shift
May 16 20:02
Sponsoring MLB jerseys
May 16 19:34
Now you frame it, now you don’t
May 16 16:56
Did Manny Pacquaio actually quote Leviticus?
May 16 16:06
Does changing your pitch frequency lead to substantial change in results?
May 16 14:18
Extra Innings: One-minute review
May 16 14:16
This particular criticism of UZR is unfounded
May 16 13:21
Psst… wanna intern for the Astros?
May 16 12:23
Arena wars
THREADS
May 16, 2012
Now you frame it, now you don’t
May 16, 2012
Dodgers’ win reversed because Mattingly did not attest to proper score!
May 16, 2012
Does changing your pitch frequency lead to substantial change in results?
May 16, 2012
Sponsoring MLB jerseys
May 15, 2012
Andre The Hawk Dawson speaks
May 15, 2012
Euro 2012 Preview
May 15, 2012
How to beat the shift
May 15, 2012
Will Pujols end the season with at least 30 HR and .500 SLG?
May 15, 2012
Kershaw v Strasburg, part 2
May 15, 2012
Did Manny Pacquaio actually quote Leviticus?
Recent comments
Older comments
Page 11 of 342 pages « First < 9 10 11 12 13 > Last »Complete Archive – By Category
Complete Archive – By Date